November 16th 2021

So you wanna make a binary do what you want? Click here to learn how.


Today I'll be telling you how to do exactly that (At least for binaries with few to none security protections)

What you're going to need:

  • A binary to exploit, find yours here (source)
  • Python
  • pwntools (pip install pwntools)
  • A server where the binary runs to exploit it (spclr.ch, port 1260)
  • gdb (Not necessary, but helps a lot; I use gef)
  • Disassembler (Not necessary if you have the source)

Note: if you don't trust the compiled binary, you can compile your own with gcc -fno-stack-protector -no-pie -o pwn pwn.c, however there might be small differences due to different compilers, so make sure to double check offsets with the provided binary


First you want to make sure you have all dependencies installed (It helps if you're on the same OS as the program will be run on, this case on Linux, not strictly necessary though).

Also if you want to debug the binary locally make sure that it doesn't contain any malicous code; or best run it in a vm / container (and don't forget to chmod +x pwn to make it runnable if you downloaded it)

Once they're installed we can go onto the second step



First we need to know what happens inside the binary, what protections are in place and maybe already get an overview where bugs might be lurking.

So first we can run pwn checksec ./pwn if pwntools is in your PATH, if it is not, you need to use the full path (python should've complained to you that it wasn't in the path when installing)

The output should look similar to this:

    Arch:     amd64-64-little
    RELRO:    Partial RELRO
    Stack:    No canary found
    NX:       NX enabled
    PIE:      No PIE (0x400000)

What does this mean? Let's start at the top: Arch: amd64-64-little just means that the binary is compiled for a little endian x86-64 machine, what you're running most likely (unless you're reading this on a mobile phone or on an M1)

RELRO: Partial RELRO means that relocations are partially read-only (I'll be honest, it's not really helping at all)

Stack: No canary found means that there is no stack cookie, that is just a 8 byte value which is placed after all values on the stack (but before the return address) which prevents the attack I'll be explaining later. This will most likely be present in any binary (You have to explicitly disable it with the -fno-stack-protector flag)

NX: NX enabled means that the binary will not let you execute anything which is data, in other words: Code is code and data is data (This can also be disabled with compiler flags)

PIE: No PIE (0x400000) means that the address where we execute the binary is not randomized at launch of the program, but instead it's always loaded at address 0x400000 (If we don't have that we would first need to figure out where the program is located in memory)

Looking at the Source / Disassembly

Now that we have some information let's take a look what we might be able to exploit.

In this case it's pretty easy to see, if you compiled it yourself the compiler will most likely even have told you that

pwn.c:(.text+0x85): warning: the `gets' function is dangerous and should not be used.

so why is that? Well easy, the gets function keeps on reading until it sees a newline:

So now it is important that we know how the stack works

The stack

The stack is where all the local variables are stored, as well as some important bits like where execution will continue once we return from the current function...

Keep in mind that this "grows" upwards (towards smaller addresses), so if we called another function we would put our current address at the top of the stack, jump to the other function and that would add it's local variables to the top again.

If we now say our 48 (0x30) bytes of input are somewhere in that stack region we can visualize it as follows:

As we now know from the gets manpage, it won't stop reading data as long as there's more data, so let's say we send a bunch of "A" characters, way more than 48, what happens then? Well, this:

Getting Data In

To get full control over the binary we first need to figure out a way to jump anywhere we want (Not always the case of course, but for now it is the basic idea)

As we've seen for that we can just send a bunch of characters, if we send random characters chances are high it crashes. Let's try that now:

Huh, we must've missed something, it didn't crash...

Let's take a look at the code again:

if(!strcmp(input, "yes")) {
    printf("Here you go: %d\n", rand());
} else {

The only explanation would be that exit call, and indeed, we see:

So we need to make sure our string starts with yes and after the yes must be a nullbyte (Which luckily get read as normal characters by gets, gets only stops on newlines)

Well, how do we get a nullbyte into the input? The quick and dirty way would be to do echo -e "yes\x00AAA...." | ./pwn the echo -e means that we replace \xyz by the character with ascii value (hex) yz.

The better option is to switch to python to handle input and output for you.

pwn template --host <server> --port <port> <binary> will generate a template for an exploit script (And print it to the terminal, redirect it into a file using > exploit.py, don't call the file pwn.py to avoid circular imports)

What does this file do? It is a wrapper to start the binary locally (using python exploit.py LOCAL) or debugging locally in gdb (using python exploit.py LOCAL GDB) or running it against the server python exploit.py.

Important Note: For gdb pwntools needs to be able to start a new terminal window, this can be easily achieved if you run your script inside tmux (inside there you can switch between the windows using Ctrl-B followed by an arrow key)

Back to the exploit.py: at the very bottom of that file you should see

io = start()

# shellcode = asm(shellcraft.sh())
# payload = fit({
#     32: 0xdeadbeef,
#     'iaaa': [1, 2, 'Hello', 3]
# }, length=128)
# io.send(payload)
# flag = io.recv(...)
# log.success(flag)


you can ignore (best remove) all the comments in that part. The start function starts the process (how is determined by the arguments you specify). The returned io object is your way of communicating with the binary/server io.recvuntil(b"?") will for example continue reading bytes (or receiving from the server) until the character was a ?. Similarily there exist a ton of functions to send (io.send(b"data here")) or wait for data. More information can be found in the docs

io.interactive() is especially nice because it allows you to interact with the binary/server as if you've launched it with ./pwn or nc <server> <port>

So now, let's start by trying to get the binary to crash, by sending yes\x00 and then a very long string of random characters (I'll use a bunch of As, which are recognizable by their hexadecimal representation 0x41)

So between the io = start() and io.interactive() we'll add a line to send that:

io = start()
io.sendline(b"yes\x00" + b"A"*100)

Don't forget the LOCAL argument when trying it out and:

We see the exit code was -11 (SIGSEGV) which means the binary actually crashed! Now onto debugging and figuring out how to jump to any location in memory we want


Now we got the crash, let's launch the exploit with argument GDB (python exploit.py LOCAL GDB) to see the crash in detail. In GDB we break at main by default, so let's enter c to continue and wait for GDB to display that it segfaulted

Huh, which A do we have to override now? Do I really have to count how many As are left and then subtract 100-x?

No, of course not, pwntools got us covered: we can use the function cyclic(num) to generate num bytes of a sequence in which 4 bytes unique determine how many bytes from the start we are. So we change the code into

io = start()
io.sendline(b"yes\x00" + cyclic(100))

Rerun in gdb to get the following:

As we can see, from $rsp onwards we got "naaaoaaa...", as I said four bytes are enough to determine where we are, we can do so by doing pwn cyclic -l naaa and we'll see that it is 52 bytes into the sequence. Now if we replace the 100 in the cyclic argument by 52, we won't crash anymore, actually we will restart the application (This is due to the fact that sendline actually send a newline character which gets replaced by a nullbyte by gets, so we actually override just the lowest byte of the return address with this)

But we can do better, we want to be able to jump anywhere, so we just need to write the bytes we want. Again pwntools helps us here by providing functions to pack numbers (addresses) into bytes (which are in the correct endianess). p64 will generate 8 bytes (for 64-bit machines, p32 will generate 4 bytes, for 32-bit machines)

So we can try to jump to address 0xdeadbeef by using this code:

io = start()
io.sendline(b"yes\x00" + cyclic(52) + p64(0xdeadbeef))

and in fact, we see:

Now onto the main meat: Getting our own code executing


We cannot write our own code anywhere (due to the NX protection). But what we can do is jump anywhere in memory. And since we know where the binary is we can jump to point in the binary which execute very little code and then return themselves. Because they return we gain control again and can jump to another location in memory doing something else. Using this method we can usually do almost everything one can do.

Want to load a register? Jump to a pop <reg>; ret instruction, put the value you want in the register after the address to that and you've just loaded some value into the register. Want to call a full function? return to the first instruction of that function to execute it.

Again pwntools got us covered: We can make a ROP object by doing rop = ROP(exe) (exe should be defined by the template)

To get a list of all gadgets we can now just do rop.gadgets and we'll get a dict with address, gadget pairs. If we just want a single gadget which does something specific, like set the rdi register we can get it's address by doing rop.find_gadget(["pop rdi", "ret"]).address, but we'll rarely use that because there is an even easier way:

We can call the rop object with a dict containing values we want the registers to have, for example rop({"rdi": 0x123}), we can get a string representation of which gadgets will be used by doing print(rop.dump()) to get the bytes to send to the binary we can use data = rop.chain().

If we want to call a function (which has a resolvable symbol in the binary, which must be the case for all functions from libc because they need to be loaded) we can use rop.call("func", []) with the arguments in the list (Example follows)

Armed with this knowledge we now must find a way to get some way to start another program on the server (Usually /bin/sh) To do this we can use different methods, the one I'll be explaining is not the easiest but neither the hardest.

We just need to call system("/bin/sh"), system being the libc function to execute programs easily. For this we need to know where in memory that function is. Since we don't even know which libc is running on the server (And every version is different) we first need to leak the version of libc. This is really easy if we can get multiple addresses to functions in libc thanks to websites like libc-db. Just enter the function names and the addresses you found.

Once we have that we need to know a location of the string /bin/sh so we can give it to system. Luckily most libc versions contain that string, which makes it pretty easy for us once we know the libc version.

Putting the theory into practice

First we need to leak the libc version. To do so we need some way to get data back to ourselves. Luckily we know that there are the printf and puts functions already in the binary (If your format string doesn't contain any formats and ends with a newline gcc will replace it by a call to puts)

So if we can call puts to print us the address of some libc functions we can determine libc using the libc database. So now the example of how to use the .call:

io = start()
r = ROP(exe)
r.call("puts", [exe.got.printf])
r.call("puts", [exe.got.puts])
r.call("puts", [exe.got.gets])
io.sendline(b"yes\x00" + cyclic(52) + r.chain())

The got contains the addresses of the libc functions, but only after they've been called at least once (Because they're being loaded lazily). This will print something like:


Which is... pretty unreadable, so let's try to convert those into numbers, pwntools has a function to undo the p64, called u64 (unpacking). However that needs exactly 8 bytes, since we are usually not using the upper two bytes of the address we need to fill the bytes up using null bytes (Since they don't get printed as they are terminator characters for C) We can read get the address (as a number) by doing this: address = u64(io.recvline()[:-1].ljust(8, b"\x00")) if the next line consists only of the address. So our exploit now looks like this:

io = start()
r = ROP(exe)
r.call("puts", [exe.got.printf])
r.call("puts", [exe.got.puts])
r.call("puts", [exe.got.gets])
io.sendline(b"yes\x00" + cyclic(52) + r.chain())

io.recvuntil(b"go: ")   # receive until the go:
io.recvline()           # receive the rest of that line

printf_addr = u64(io.recvline()[:-1].ljust(8, b"\x00"))
puts_addr   = u64(io.recvline()[:-1].ljust(8, b"\x00"))
gets_addr   = u64(io.recvline()[:-1].ljust(8, b"\x00"))
info("Got printf:%x, puts: %x, gets: %x", printf_addr, puts_addr, gets_addr)


This will print three addresses, plugging them into the libc database will result in multiple libc version which match (Make sure to not accidentally leak your local libc version)

If we want to do some fancy stuff we would be interested in downloading the full libc and maybe loading it into pwntools, but that's not necessary for us, what we're interested in are just three addresses (visible when clicking on any of the blue libc names on the right): an address of a leaked function (For example in our case printf would have an offset 0x58230), the offset of system (In this case 0x49de0) and finally the offset to the /bin/sh string, (str_bin_sh, 0x18bb62).

Equipped with these values we can now make our exploit: If we know the address of printf, we can calculate the start of libc by doing libc_base = printf_address - 0x58230, from that we can calculate addresses to the system function and the /bin/sh string in memory using the corresponding offsets from the libc base.

Now it's only a matter of calling system with the input... But how can we make our rop dependent on output it generates?

We can't, but what we can do is after leaking the addresses of the libc functions, to just jump back to the main function, so

r = ROP(exe)
r.call("puts", [exe.got.printf])
r.call("puts", [exe.got.puts])
r.call("puts", [exe.got.gets])

With this we can make another input, which can overflow the stack yet again. This time however we have the correct pointers (Because they are only randomized at the start of the program), we just need to the whole process of exploiting the overflow again. This task is left to the reader as an exercise. (Go get that flag)

Some quick notes: if you want to debug locally you might need different offsets, you can check if the LOCAL argument is present with the args.LOCAL variable.

More notes

If you want to do fancy stuff (by loading the libc), you probably also want to load different libcs based on if you're exploiting locally or not. You can do this using libc = ELF("/usr/lib/libc.so.6") if args.LOCAL else ELF("./libc.so.6") If you have the correct libc for the server in the current directory.

Then you can set the correct base address of libc by doing libc.address = ..... where ... is the libc_base we calculated before. If you don't do that all the stuff discussed after this point will just give you relative offsets from libc base, if you set it it will give you the full address (Basically just a constant added) When using it in an exploit you usually need to full address.

To get the address of system you can then use libc.sym.system (similar for all other libc functions like libc.sym.printf etc.) To get the location of a /bin/sh string you can use next(libc.search(b"/bin/sh\x00"))

< BSidesTLV2022 Writeups | DH MITM >